Thursday, September 24, 2009

Miss Brill

Katharine Mansfield, the author of "Miss Brill," uses the protaginist of the story, Miss Brill, to present the story. Miss Brill is a very judgemental character,she goes to a park in France every Sunday and watches the people and makes several judgements about them. Miss Brill sits on a bench and listens to a band and judges how the band plays. When on the bench, Miss Brill will get frustrated if the person next to her doesn't start a conversation with her. With the descriptions that Mansfield makes, you can judge that Miss Brill is a hermit, who doesn't have much of a social life and depends on other people to live her life for her. As the story progresses Miss Brill begins to think that life is a stage and all the people are actors and all of their behaviors are part of the act, and she still sits on the bench observing the people and making assumptions about themand enjoys their behavior. With these attributes Mansfield displays a picture to the reader that Miss Brill has low self esteem because all she does is judge other people and doesn't ever judge herself, also the reader can see that Miss Brill has no social life, is a loner, and is kind of crazy with her thought process that life is a stage. Also, Mansfield creates irony through Miss Brill in that Miss Brill is a teacher and should be an example to children, but with the way she acts you'd think that she is a child. Mansfield creates symbolism through the fox fur that Miss Brill wears, because the fox fur, like Miss Brill, goes out every Sunday, and stays caged in all week, is old and unwanted. Katherine Mansfield did a wonderful job depicting the character of Miss Brill, as a reader you could easily tell that Miss Brill was a judgemental loner, who had no social life, and depended on others to live her life for her, you could tell this thorugh Mansfield's literary elements.

7 comments:

  1. You did very well depicting the question and using the literary elements of the story as your basis for a thorough answer. One thing that you forgot to add in is how the people that Miss Brill listens in on are foil characters of herself and how she goes back to her cupboard, not realizeng that she is worse than everyone she just saw come out of their little cupboards.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Good job at showing the characteristics of Miss Brill. One thing you could of done was explain why she was childish a little more, but nice job.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Overall you did a good job at describing how Mansfield characterizes the protagonist, Ms. Brill. I would have provided more specific examples of how she judges the men and women at the park. For example, when Ms. Brill puts extreme judgement on the Ermine Toque, when in reality these two characters are almost identical in the fact that they are very hypocritical of everyone around them, therefor refusing to recognize their own faults.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think you did a very good job at showing the qualities of Miss Brill, although you could of gone into a little bit more detail to back up your position.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Miss Brill is everything but Brilliant!

    ReplyDelete
  7. Betway Casino Review, Promo Code & Welcome Bonus
    › casino-promo-code › 거제 출장샵 casino-promo-code 충청남도 출장샵 Sports 동해 출장샵 Betway Casino offers a massive welcome bonus package worth up to $1,000. The Betway welcome bonus 성남 출장안마 is an exclusive offer to new players that are  Deposit Bonus: 200% up to $1,000Welcome Bonus: 200% up to $1,000. Rating: 4 Review by JT Hub 부천 출장샵

    ReplyDelete